James Sullivan“It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent that survives. It is the one that is the most adaptable to change”



The valuation differential between traditional value and growth indices has been at record levels; never before has this disconnect been so great. Therefore the ‘value versus growth’ argument is as ripe today as it has been for some time, yet it remains one I find rather opaque.

Benjamin Graham’s The Intelligent Investor, published in 1949, went a long way to explain value investing.  However, definitions of what constitutes ‘value’ today vary, and stocks and sectors migrate from value to growth and back again, meaning it is not easy to compare the behaviour of an index today to one from twenty years ago.

For example, some commentators would have you believe that technology stocks are growth stocks, but once the cash is stripped out, and forward earnings are observed, many technology stocks would trade on traditional value metrics. Similarly, in the past one would be forgiven for suggesting dividends are a value trait, yet the last 10 years has witnessed dividend paying stocks amongst the most expensive in the market.

I spoke to a friend about value investing last week, and how some are now looking very cheap by historical standards; his response was ‘…that’s because they’re bad companies’. He may have a point and I respect his opinion, but I’m not sure tarring all lowly valued companies with the same brush is quite fair either.

I recently stumbled across the ‘Death by Amazon Index’, which was created by a US based advisory group, Bespoke Investment Group, in 2014. It is home to about 50 stocks that haven’t embraced technology, and were therefore obvious victims of the Amazon and wider technological revolution. Unsurprisingly the index in question has performed poorly (despite a promising start) versus the broader market.

It’s not as simple as saying all technology companies are good, and all traditional companies are bad, but this to me is a much cleaner argument to articulate and grasp. Categorising the stocks in this way is perhaps the new and improved ‘value versus growth’ trade. Those embracing appropriate levels of technology and those that aren’t. Those that aren’t afraid to change tack and those that are. Those that can disrupt and those that will be disrupted.

Some value companies will adapt and thrive, others won’t.

As investors we have a duty of care to remain style agnostic, investing only where we see the support of consumer trends and behaviours. Being able to find companies and sectors that trade on below average multiples whilst embracing technology is what separates the mundane from the great.

After such a long period of underperformance of value as an investment style, there is a plausible argument suggesting we will witness a reversion to mean, and we should be long value stocks. I’m not convinced that the old rules apply as simply in a world that has moved on from 1949.

Terms & Conditions


By using or accessing any part of our website, aside from the Terms and Conditions page, you agree to be legally bound by those terms and conditions. We may amend these terms and conditions at any time without notice. Your continued use of our website following any change will constitute your acceptance of such change. Our full terms and conditions can be found at https://www.mitonoptimal.com/uk/terms-conditions/

Regulatory Information

The MitonOptimal Group (“MitonOptimal”) of companies is authorised and regulated in their respective jurisdictions, as required by law. For further details, you may visit the regional sites via https://www.mitonoptimal.com.

MitonOptimal UK Limited is part of the MitonOptimal group of companies. MitonOptimal UK Limited is registered in England and Wales No. 09138865. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Risk Warning

Potential investors should be aware that our models and funds may make investments in equities, bonds, cash, commodities alternative strategies and commercial property. Investors should be aware that there is no guarantee that investments will go up.  Past performance is no guide as to future performance. As the price of units and the amount of income distributed or accumulated may go down as well as up, the Manager has no obligation to redeem units at the subscription price originally paid. If you are in any doubt about the content of these terms and conditions, you should not enter the site and consult your stockbroker, bank manager, solicitor, accountant or professional investment advisors.

If you have any questions or concerns about our website please email us at [email protected].

Please indicate below, whether you accept/do not accept our terms and conditions of use.


MitonOptimal UK Limited
Royal Mead
Railway Place


t: +44 (0) 1225 632 250
f: +44 (0) 1225 439 442

Regulatory Information

MitonOptimal UK Limited is part of the MitonOptimal group of companies. Registered in England and Wales No. 09138865. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.